I am not exactly a T.V. person; I would rather listen to the
radio while doing other more productive (or not so productive) things. However,
even if you are not a T.V. person living in the Arab world, it is quiet easy to
notice that every once in a while, television channels of the Arab world are
invaded with a new phenomenon; from talk shows that are copies of more popular
western ones, to translated versions of game shows. The new phenomenon in the
Arab world right now is dubbed series and movies –knowing that dubbing has
always been around, but these days, it is… PHENOMINAL.
You would be watching television one day, and come across
Turkish series dubbed in Syrian accent, American series in Lebanese accent, and
Indian movies in dialect belonging to a country of the Arab Gulf. I have to
admit that I have never watched any of those series or movies fully, but I did
get an idea about them as I changed between channels on few occasions.
My impression of the few shots that I watched could be described
in one word: Disastrous. If we try to forget about the awkwardness of the
scenes where well known English speaking actors and actresses are speaking
Arabic, we are left with the automatic elimination of very important drama elements.
In respectable drama writing; authors carefully assign different accents, dialects
or language to their different characters to send messages about those character's
backgrounds, environments, educational levels… etc. and this is something that
is killed by dubbing. But then again, how would we know; a huge percentage of drama
writers in the Arab world use the same language in dialogues between
their characters; educated or not, they all speak the same language.
Moral of the story: Stop Dubbing Movies/Series…
A-more-serious moral of the story: We need to start
trying to understand more of the stuff we watch on T.V. Not all of it could be counted
as a mere pass time activity; some actually have messages hidden in the
simplest gestures and words.
No comments:
Post a Comment